Punt & Kickoff Return Depth Charts and Players to Target

Punt & Kickoff Return Depth Charts and Players to Target

By Brandon Niles (4for4 Scout), last update Sep 10, 2018

Brandon Niles's picture

Brandon has been a regular contributor to 4for4 since 2006. He's an experienced writer with a background in communication, business and alcoholic beverages.

Follow Brandon Niles on Twitter: @2guysbrandon.

With a well-timed touchdown, a kickoff or punt returner can provide the key points that push your fantasy team over the top. Some returners are better than others, so it’s important for fantasy owners to keep an eye on depth charts to see which players will return kicks and punts for each team. Below you will find kickoff and punt return depth charts. They will be updated weekly— through the seemingly endless amounts of drops, pickups, and training camp battles—until the season begins.

2018 Punt & Kick Returner Depth Charts
Team PR Position KR Position
Arizona Christian Kirk WR T.J. Logan RB
Arizona Patrick Peterson CB Christian Kirk WR
Arizona T.J. Logan RB J.J. Nelson WR
Atlanta Justin Hardy WR Justin Hardy WR
Atlanta Marvin Hall WR Marvin Hall WR
Baltimore Janarion Grant WR Janarion Grant WR
Baltimore Jordan Lasley WR Chris Moore WR
Buffalo Marcus Murphy RB Taiwan Jones RB
Buffalo Jeremy Kerley WR Marcus Murphy RB
Buffalo Taiwan Jones RB Ray-Ray McCloud WR
Carolina Christian McCaffrey RB Damiere Byrd WR
Carolina Damiere Byrd WR Christian McCaffrey RB
Chicago Tarik Cohen RB Benny Cunningham RB
Chicago Bryce Callahan WR Tarik Cohen RB
Cincinnati Alex Erickson WR Alex Erickson WR
Cincinnati Tyler Boyd WR Darius Phillips CB
Cleveland Jabrill Peppers S Jabrill Peppers S
Cleveland Antonio Callaway WR Antonio Callaway WR
Dallas Jourdan Lewis CB Jourdan Lewis CB
Dallas Tavon Austin WR Tavon Austin WR
Denver Phillip Lindsay RB Phillip Lindsay RB
Denver DaeSean Hamilton WR Adam Jones CB
Detroit Jamal Agnew CB Jamal Agnew CB
Detroit T.J. Jones WR Ameer Abdullah RB
Detroit Ameer Abdullah RB T.J. Jones WR
Green Bay Trevor Davis WR Trevor Davis WR
Green Bay Jaire Alexander CB Marquez Valdes-Scantling WR
Houston Tyler Ervin RB Tyler Ervin RB
Houston Will Fuller WR Bruce Ellington WR
Indianapolis Nyheim Hines RB Nyheim Hines RB
Indianapolis Chester Rogers WR Marlon Mack RB
Indianapolis Ryan Grant WR Chester Rogers WR
Jacksonville Jaydon Mickens WR Corey Grant RB
Jacksonville Dede Westbrook WR Dede Westbrook WR
Jacksonville Rashad Greene WR Rashad Greene WR
Kansas City Tyreek Hill WR DeAnthony Thomas WR
Kansas City DeAnthony Thomas WR Tyreek Hill WR
Kansas City  Tremon Smith CB Damien Williams RB
LA Chargers Travis Benjamin WR Desmond King CB
LA Chargers Desmond King CB Austin Ekeler RB
LA Chargers J.J. Jones WR J.J. Jones WR
LA Rams Pharoh Cooper WR Pharoh Cooper WR
Miami Jakeem Grant WR Jakeem Grant WR
Miami Danny Amendola WR Senorise Perry RB
Miami Albert Wilson WR Kalen Ballage RB
Minnesota Marcus Sherels CB Marcus Sherels CB
Minnesota Mike Hughes CB Mike Hughes CB
Minnesota Stacy Coley WR Stacy Coley WR
New England Patrick Chung S Cordarrelle Patterson WR
New England Julian Edelman WR Matt Slater WR
New Orleans Ted Ginn WR Tommylee Lewis WR
New Orleans Tommylee Lewis WR Ted Ginn RB
NY Giants Kaelin Clay WR Cody Latimer WR
NY Giants Sterling Shepard WR Kaelin Clay WR
NY Jets Andre Roberts WR Andre Roberts WR
NY Jets Trenton Cannon RB Trenton Cannon RB
Oakland Dwayne Harris WR Dwayne Harris WR
Oakland Jalen Richard RB Nick Nelson CB
Philadelphia Darren Sproles RB Darren Sproles RB
Philadelphia Corey Clement RB Corey Clement RB
Pittsburgh Antonio Brown WR JuJu Smith-Schuster WR
Pittsburgh Ryan Switzer WR Ryan Switzer WR
Pittsburgh Cam Sutton CB Cam Sutton CB
San Francisco Trent Taylor WR Matt Breida RB
San Francisco Dante Pettis WR Victor Bolden WR
San Francisco D.J. Reed CB Dante Pettis WR
Seattle Tyler Lockett WR Tyler Lockett WR
Tampa Bay Adam Humphries WR Jacquizz Rodgers RB
Tampa Bay DeSean Jackson WR Shaun Wilson RB
Tennessee Adoree Jackson CB Adoree Jackson CB
Tennessee Taywan Taylor WR Dion Lewis RB
Washington Jamison Crowder WR Greg Stroman CB
Washington Greg Stroman CB Maurice Harris WR

New Rules

To further protect players from the bone-crushing hits and high-impact collisions of kickoff returns, the league has adopted new rules for the kicking game. While punt returns will remain unchanged, the new rules for kickoffs will impact how many kicks a team takes out of the end zone and how effective the returns are. Here’s an overview of the changes:

  • Teams must line up five players on each side of the ball, instead of a minimum of four players. This will mostly affect the strategy behind onside kicks, where teams would load one side of the field with six players under the previous rule.
  • The kicking team must line up within one yard behind the line of scrimmage. This has been five yards in the past and will limit the running start of coverage teams prior to the kick.
  • No wedge blocks allowed. Previously, two-player wedge blocks were allowed at any stage of the field. Now, only players lined up in the setup zone prior to the kick can come together for a block.
  • A player no longer needs to down the ball in the end zone for a touchback. The touchback is called the moment the ball touches the ground in the end zone.
  • Coverage teams are required to have at least two players outside the hash marks on either side of the field and return teams need at least eight players in the set-up zone. This change will decrease the intensity of collisions by changing the initial blocking locations and by reversing blocking direction.

What do these rule changes mean? Well, mostly they mean a shift in philosophy for coaches around the league. But for the players listed in this article, it likely means more returns, and more diversity in players touching the ball. While kickers with huge legs will continue to boom the ball out the back of the end zone whenever possible, teams may use more directional and pooch kicks to take advantage of where the best gunners are. In short, expect more returns, and up to three sure-handed players ready to return to account for less predictable ball placement.

Double Dip: Fantasy Studs Who Return Kicks

Many teams have game-breaking playmakers on offense they can’t help but use in the return game as well. This is where fantasy owners in return yardage leagues should stand up and take notice. With the amount of talent and speed at the skill positions throughout the league, multiple teams are using these dual-threat options as multi-purpose offensive weapons, as well as dynamite players in the return game. Only players whose value increases are included. Players like Antonio Brown, who inexplicably continues to return punts, won’t be mentioned because they’re going to be top picks regardless. The following players will likely get a boost and should be considered for their added return value:

  • Tarik Cohen, RB, Bears — With former Chiefs offensive coordinator Matt Nagy now the head coach in Chicago, Cohen has been getting buzz as the player most likely to fill the Tyreek Hill role in the new offense. Cohen did a little of everything last year, finishing with 723 combined yards and three touchdowns on offense, along with an additional 855 yards and a touchdown in the return game. While Eddie Jackson and Benny Cunningham are likely to still be options as returners, expect Cohen to build upon his strong rookie season and be one of the most interesting multi-threat fantasy options available this year.
  • Tyreek Hill, WR, Chiefs — Hill took on an expanded role on offense last season, but still maintained his job as the primary punt returner. He finished the season with 204 return yards and ran back a punt for a touchdown. He should continue to be a versatile threat for the Chiefs. With his immense playmaking talent, it’s hard to believe they won’t continue to use him on punt returns. In fantasy leagues that reward return yardage, Hill goes from being a solid WR2 to a borderline WR1.
  • Christian Kirk, WR, Cardinals — Kirk isn’t guaranteed to win the job in Arizona, but he was dynamic in college and will be given every chance to compete. The Cardinals have a new special teams coach after a horrible season in the return game last year. Kirk will compete with second-year running back T.J. Logan primarily for return duties, but he should wind up with at least a few returns. On top of that, Kirk has only Brice Butler, J.J. Nelson, and Chad Williams to contend with for snaps on offense opposite Larry Fitzgerald. With his playmaking ability, expect new head coach Steve Wilks to find ways to get the ball in Kirk’s hands as much as possible.
  • Christian McCaffrey, RB, Panthers — McCaffrey wasn’t quite as dynamic as expected coming out of Stanford last season, but he did wind up returning 22 punts and three kicks for a total of 220 return yards. His offensive production is significant, though. He caught 80 balls, third among running backs, and he finished the year with 1,086 yards and seven touchdowns on offense. McCaffrey should retain the punt return job and his role on offense should only expand. It’s possible the Panthers try to limit his exposure on special teams, so watch the training camp and preseason progress of receivers Damiere Byrd and Curtis Samuel.
  • Ted Ginn Jr., WR, Saints — Ginn will share return duties with Tommylee Lewis again this year, but it’s hard to imagine the Saints continuing to expose Alvin Kamara to vicious hits in the return game. Ginn should continue to be a primary option in the slot on offense, while also getting the bulk of the work on punt returns. He returned a total of 24 kicks on special teams last year, though he only gained 159 yards. However, even that modest help to his production on offense—53 catches, 787 yards, and four touchdowns last season—gives him additional value in return leagues. 
  • Dante Pettis, WR, 49ers — Pettis is no sure thing to win a job on offense or on special teams. However, the 49ers invested a second-round pick in the playmaker out of Washington and they’ll likely find ways to get him the ball. Pettis was an amazing punt returner in college—finishing his career with nine punt returns for touchdowns, including four last year. On offense, he scored 22 touchdowns over his past two seasons, including 15 as a junior in 2016. Pettis isn’t worth investing a high draft pick on—at least not in redraft leagues—but he’s worth stashing. He’ll be fighting Trent Taylor for work in the slot, but he’ll likely beat out the suspended Victor Bolden and Kendrick Bourne in the return game, as well as when the team goes four-wide on offense.
  • Tyler Lockett, WR, Seahawks — Lockett was the primary returner in Seattle last season, and averaged 25.6 yards on 37 kick returns, even returning one kick for a touchdown. Combined with 36 punt returns, he finished with 1,186 total return yards, second in the league. Lockett has also caught at least 40 passes and 500 yards in each of his three pro seasons, including 45 and 555 last year, and he should continue to get looks on the offensive side of the ball. The Seahawks lost Paul Richardson in free agency, and while they brought in Jaron Brown and Brandon Marshall, Lockett will be given every opportunity to compete for a starting role opposite Doug Baldwin, so an uptick in offensive production could be in store.

Other names to consider: Danny Amendola, WR, Dolphins; Travis Benjamin, WR, Chargers; Darren Sproles, RB, Eagles; Tavon Austin, WR, Cowboys

Just for Kicks: Return-Only Specialists

Some players carve out a niche as a return-specialist and make a roster on that skill alone. If you’re not in a league with an extra slot for returners, the players below are unlikely to create enough production on offense to make a real difference, but they can be valuable in leagues that allow you to start a separate returner.

  • Cordarrelle Patterson, WR, Patriots — Patterson has been one of the best kick returners in the league throughout his career, and now that he’s a Patriot, there’s no reason to think he won’t continue to thrive in that role. Patterson has a chance to contribute on offense as well, so he may have some dual-role potential, but he’s most likely to remain simply a Pro Bowl caliber return specialist.
  • Pharoh Cooper, WR, Rams — Cooper was one of the best returners in football last season. Among players with 20 kick returns or more, he led the league with a 27.4-yard average, and his 12.5-yard punt return average was second to only Jamal Agnew of the Lions. Cooper also took a kick back for a touchdown. He’d love to see more time on offense but is unlikely to rise higher than fourth on the depth chart, making it hard to envision him holding value in leagues that don’t separate the returner spot.
  • Ryan Switzer, WR, Raiders — The Raiders will need to replace Cordarrelle Patterson as a returner and Switzer was excellent in that role for the Cowboys last season. He averaged 25.0 yards on 24 kick returns and he took a punt back for a touchdown. Switzer will have a chance to compete for snaps in the slot on offense, but with a crowded depth chart in Oakland, it’s hard to imagine him getting an opportunity to be a dual-threat player. Still, he should have no trouble winning both the punt and kick return positions. Update: Switzer traded to the Steelers. Switzer is still likely to be primarily a return specialist, but he has a chance to earn a job in the slot as well. The Raiders will likely turn to Dwayne Harris, who will have very little offensive value but is an accomplished return specialist. 

Other returners unlikely to play a significant role on offense: Trevor Davis, WR, Packers; Kaelin Clay, WR, Bills; Jakeem Grant, WR, Dolphins; Bernard Reedy, WR, Buccaneers; Kalif Raymond, WR, Giants; Tyler Ervin, RB, Texans; Chester Rogers, WR, Colts

NFL Teams with Open Kickoff or Punt Return Jobs

There is always a lot of turnover at both return spots from year-to-year, and below are a few of the teams that have open jobs where a young playmaker might be able to earn a spot on the roster.  

  • Falcons Andre Roberts went to the Jets, so the Falcons will have an open competition. The likely winners are Justin Hardy and Marvin Hall, two receivers who will also be battling it out for the fourth spot on the depth chart. The winner will likely be a return-specialist only.
  • Redskins Jamison Crowder could be an option as a dual-role fantasy target, but he wasn’t particularly effective returning punts last season, averaging only 6.3 yards on 27 returns. Washington will give the youngsters on the roster every opportunity to win the job. Candidates include cornerback Greg Stroman, and receivers Trey Quinn and Darvin Kidsy.
  • Steelers — There’s a chance JuJu Smith-Schuster wins the primary kick return job, and if that happens, his value will get a bump in leagues that reward return yardage. Keep an eye on the competition though, as the Steelers would love nothing more than for a young guy like Quadree Henderson—who is not a focal point of the offense—to wrestle away both returner jobs. Update: Ryan Switzer was traded to the Steelers and should be considered the primary option to replace Antonio Brown and JuJu Smith-Schuster in the return game. 

Other teams with an open competition for return jobs: Ravens, Bengals, Jets, Jaguars, Broncos

IDP Love: Defensive Players Who Return Kicks

If you play in an IDP league, there are always a few corners or safeties who bolster their stats with returns. While teams have sometimes suffered consequences of injuries using their top defenders in the return game, a few teams inevitably continue to expose significant starters to brutal hits on special teams. These players are especially worth noting in leagues that require a cornerback slot, as cornerbacks are often low fantasy producers, and return stats can help bolster their value.

  • Adoree Jackson, CB, Titans — Jackson was the primary returner for the Titans last season, returning 25 kicks and 34 punts for 868 yards. While he may lose some work to free agent acquisitions Michael Campanaro and Dion Lewis, he should continue to get work in the return game. Jackson is a dynamic playmaker with the ball in his hands, with blazing speed and excellent agility. His development as a future star cornerback makes him an intriguing option for fantasy leagues that have a separate spot for cornerbacks. In leagues where owners get points for return yardage, Jackson may even challenge some safeties in IDP value.
  • Jabrill Peppers, DB, Browns — The Browns lined Peppers up all over the defensive backfield last season but will probably move him closer to the line of scrimmage this year in more of a traditional strong safety role. He should continue to see time in the return game as well. Last year, he returned 14 kicks and 30 punts for a total of 498 yards. While he’ll get some competition from running back Matthew Dayes and rookie receiver Antonio Callaway, Peppers is too much of a playmaker to be left completely out of the mix. His changing role on defense and his help in the return game should lead to more tackles and more fantasy value in IDP leagues that provide points for returns.
  • Mike Hughes, CB, Vikings — Keep an eye on the Vikings’ first-round pick this year. Hughes was very good in the return game at the college level, returning two kicks and one punt for touchdowns last season at UCF. Hughes may not win the job over veteran Marcus Sherels but if he does, he has a good chance to contribute in dime situations on defense and rack up stats as a returner as well.

Other defensive backs to watch for: Jamal Agnew, CB, Lions; Micah Hyde, DB, Bills


Related Articles

J.J. Jones
Filed Under:
Preseason
,
2018