Five Quarterbacks, Zero Fantasy Confidence: The Jerry Jeudy Problem

After a career-best 2024 season, Jerry Jeudy established himself as a capable NFL receiver following his trade from Denver to Cleveland. He posted 90 receptions for 1,229 yards and four touchdowns on 145 targets, earning a three-year, $58 million contract extension that locked him in through 2027. However, his production was heavily dependent on quarterback play, and Cleveland's uncertain quarterback situation creates significant risk for his 2025 outlook. Currently being drafted as WR38, Jeudy represents a volume-based play with major downside if (when) the Browns' quarterback situation deteriorates.

Click here for more 2025 Player Profiles!

DraftKings is giving ALL customers a can't-miss offer for Best Ball: Draft One, Get One! Enter a lineup in the $15 Million Best Ball Contest for just $20, and you'll score another Best Ball ticket to play FREE for a share of $15 million—giving you a second shot to win big!

Career-Best Production Built on Volume

Jeudy's 2024 breakout was primarily driven by opportunity rather than efficiency. His 145 targets ranked among the top 20 wide receivers, while his 89.9% snap share demonstrated Cleveland's commitment to featuring him prominently. The 8.5 targets per game represented a significant increase from his Denver years and provided the foundation for his career-best statistical output.

The raw numbers tell an encouraging story—1,229 receiving yards represented a career-high by a significant margin, nearly 500 yards more than his previous best. His 90 receptions also set a personal record, showcasing his ability to handle significant target volume when given the opportunity. The production was particularly strong in the second half of the season, with Jeudy averaging 101.4 yards per game compared to just 48.9 in the first half, coinciding with Cleveland's quarterback changes.

The Quarterback Dependency Problem

Jeudy's 2024 production hinged almost entirely on quarterback play, creating a troubling precedent for 2025 projections. With Deshaun Watson under center, Jeudy averaged just three catches and 38 receiving yards per game across seven starts. This anemic production highlighted the poor chemistry and limited downfield passing that characterized Watson's play.

The transformation under Jameis Winston was dramatic—Jeudy averaged seven catches and 112.3 yards per game during Winston's seven starts. This was a complete reversal in productivity, with Winston's willingness to target Jeudy downfield unlocking the receiver's potential for explosive plays. His two biggest games of the season came with Winston at quarterback, including a 235-yard performance in Denver.

Even backup quarterbacks Dorian Thompson-Robinson and Bailey Zappe produced better results than Watson. The consistent theme was that virtually any quarterback other than Watson could generate meaningful production with Jeudy.

2025 Quarterback Uncertainty

Cleveland enters 2025 with perhaps the most uncertain quarterback situation in the NFL. The Browns currently roster five quarterbacks, which typically indicates a lack of confidence in any single option. Watson's availability remains questionable, while the alternatives present their own limitations.

Kenny Pickett appears positioned to compete for the starting role despite his underwhelming Pittsburgh tenure. Joe Flacco returns at age 40 after a disappointing stint in Indianapolis, where he averaged 7.1 yards per attempt and threw seven interceptions in eight games. The Browns also added Shedeur Sanders, who may factor into the competition, but it remains to be seen whether or not he can immediately support consistent receiver production.

The coaching staff's approach under Kevin Stefanski has historically favored more conservative, run-heavy schemes when quarterback play is uncertain. This philosophical shift away from the aggressive downfield passing that benefited Jeudy under Winston could significantly limit his ceiling, even if he maintains his target share.

Route Running and Role Considerations

Jeudy's elite route-running ability remains his greatest asset, with many considering him among the most technically sound receivers in the NFL. His 42 routes per game ranked first among all wide receivers, demonstrating both his durability and the Browns' reliance on his skill set. However, his effectiveness varied significantly based on alignment, averaging 1.76 yards per route run in the slot compared to 1.86 when lined up outside.

With the addition of Diontae Johnson and the departure of Elijah Moore, Jeudy may see increased slot usage in 2025. While this could provide more consistent short-area targets, it may limit his opportunities for the explosive downfield plays that drove his late-season surge.

The three-year extension provides job security but also raises expectations for consistent production. Cleveland's investment suggests they view Jeudy as a cornerstone piece, but the financial commitment may not translate to fantasy success if the supporting infrastructure fails to develop.

The Bottom Line

• Volume-driven breakout with efficiency concerns - Posted career-highs with 90 receptions for 1,229 yards on 145 targets, but his 62.1% catch rate and 8.5 yards per target ranked below average for receivers with similar usage.

• Extreme quarterback dependency - Averaged just 3 catches and 38 yards per game with Deshaun Watson compared to 7 catches and 112.3 yards with Jameis Winston, highlighting massive variance based on quarterback play.

• Major uncertainty at quarterback position - Cleveland currently has five quarterbacks on the roster with no clear starter, creating significant risk for consistent target quality and offensive philosophy in 2025.

• High-risk investment despite volume potential - While his 145 targets provide a foundation for production, the extreme quarterback dependency makes him too volatile for reliable fantasy planning.

• Avoid Jeudy in drafts - The combination of Cleveland's uncertain quarterback situation and his proven inability to produce with poor quarterback play creates too much downside risk, even at WR38 pricing.