Discuss your team
Scott Pagel Favourite NFL team: [field_favorite_nfl_team]
Scott has been a weekly sports editor of four local papers, and a sports writer for the Times News newspaper for over 12 years, covering anything from youth to pro sports and everything in between in eastern PA. He's been a contributor to 4for4.com since 2005 and has been playing fantasy football since the late 1990s. Scott has covered Philadelphia Eagles training camp since 1997 and primarily covers the Eagles for 4for4.com.
Brandon Niles Favourite NFL team: [field_favorite_nfl_team]
Brandon has been a regular contributor to 4for4 since 2006. He's an experienced writer with a background in communication and business. Brandon currently serves as the National Sports Commentary writer for Big Sky Weekly. An avid fan and long time fantasy junkie, Brandon follows every team closely and has covered the Ravens, Giants, Patriots, and Colts in his tenure at 4for4.
Last update · Apr 23 · 8:30 AM EDT
With Scott Pagel and Brandon Niles

Welcome to 4for4.com's Discuss Your Team forum. Here 4for4 members can converse freely with 4for4 scouts about trade evaluations, draft advice, and team questions. Whether you have site specific questions, important fantasy decisions to make, or you just want to chat about your favorite team, please stop by and join the conversation. Our scouts share your love and passion for fantasy football!

Posted by tommybahama yesterday · 4:04 PM EDT

I'm picking 9 in a 10 team .5 ppr league. I can keep Saquon for the 9th pick, or CMac for my second rounder.

I'm thinking it makes more sense to keep Saquon and take the best WR available...

I'm picking 9 in a 10 team .5 ppr league. I can keep Saquon for the 9th pick, or CMac for my second rounder.

I'm thinking it makes more sense to keep Saquon and take the best WR available in the 2nd rather than keeping McCaffrey and hoping Adams or Hopkins falls to me at 9.

Who would you keep?

See more
Posted by clinkletter yesterday · 3:19 PM EDT

Guys, in a 5 player keeper league. These are my current options:

1) ...

Guys, in a 5 player keeper league. These are my current options:

1) Melvin Gordon
2) Nick Chubb
3) Joe Mixon
4) Travis Kelce
5) Chris Godwin/Brandin Cooks/Philip Lindsay

I really like Calvin Ridley and more so from a keeper perspective. so i have some trade options.

I could trade a third rounder (8th in non keepers) to keep him and also ive been offered a 2nd (7th in non keepers) and diggs for kelce.

I think Kelce had a career year and may actually decrease and he used to have injury woes, no? I used to love cooks but i think diggs can get more production from targets and ridley could break out. i do like godwin and am a bucs fan.

Would you guys do this trade? Im worried about losing kelce but the trades to get diggs and ridley to go along with my running backs sound exciting.

See more
Posted by salyourpal yesterday · 12:59 AM EDT

Hello

I have #5 overall, if Gordon signs prior to draft I want him (assuming top 4 doesn't drop), If not I am not sure if I want RB (not fond of Johnson) or D Adams. I also like Chubb for...

Hello

I have #5 overall, if Gordon signs prior to draft I want him (assuming top 4 doesn't drop), If not I am not sure if I want RB (not fond of Johnson) or D Adams. I also like Chubb for some reason but Hunt scares me.

With the 2nd pick I am thinking of getting Kittle in Rd 2. Thoughts?

*My league is 1/2 ppr BUT TE are 1 pt ppr.

Lastly who do you think has more depth rb or wr?

Thanks.

See more
Posted by Slappjack Jul 20 · 5:58 PM EDT

So just joined a 14 team superflex dynasty. I have never played in a superflex league before so I'm looking for some draft strategy tips. I'm out of the 12 spot in a snake. I'm a zero RB guy so I'...

So just joined a 14 team superflex dynasty. I have never played in a superflex league before so I'm looking for some draft strategy tips. I'm out of the 12 spot in a snake. I'm a zero RB guy so I'm thinking of going QB with my 1st and second. Also how early do you grab a 3rd QB?

See more
Posted by OscillateWildly Jul 19 · 5:05 PM EDT

Current team prior to this year’s draft. We get to keep 2 players and I’m asking for help. Here’s my current roster before they wiped it clean except for the 2 we keep.

Mahomes
...

Current team prior to this year’s draft. We get to keep 2 players and I’m asking for help. Here’s my current roster before they wiped it clean except for the 2 we keep.

Mahomes
Kamara
D. Williams
J. Jackson
M. Mack
J. Wilson
K. Drake
D. Adams
J. Jones
K. Galladay
D. Baldwin
D. Njoku

See more
Posted by Saephansf Jul 18 · 4:10 PM EDT

Hi all,

Who should I select as my one keeper? Below is a list of players and their drafted positions in () from last year. Whomever I select will determine which draft round I lose during...

Hi all,

Who should I select as my one keeper? Below is a list of players and their drafted positions in () from last year. Whomever I select will determine which draft round I lose during this year’s draft.

Possible Keeper:
Melvin Gordon (1st), Mark Ingram (4th), Tevin Coleman (5th), Golden Tate (6th), Robby Anderson (7th), Trey Burton (8th), Kenny Stills (10th), Austin Ekeler (12th)

Unfortunately, my keeper decision is a little cloudy with my options. With Gordon’s contract issues, his VBR list him as RB-19, which is behind Ingram (RB-18). Essentially, it does not appears I have a stud-player.

This is a 12-team, non-ppr league, RB-heavy league.

Here’s a list of projected keepers from the 11-league mgrs. Note: Each comma (,) represents a manager’s projected keeper.

McCaffrey, M Mack, Kittle, Kelce or Mahomes, Barkley, D Henry, Ertz/Mixon or Luck, Edelman, Hopkins, Kamara/M Thomas/AJ Green, and D Johnson/Guice or Kupp.

Lastly, love the new platform. 3-year 4for4 subscriber. Definitely more user-friendly. What I would like to see is a printable cheat sheet for the Depth Chart. It’s been a key tool for me to identify RB handcuffs and WR2/3s by team on later rounds, so it’ll good to have the data in one (or two) page. Our draft is live and internet is restricted so as you can imagine, there’s tons of paper to sort/organize. 😊

Thank you!

See more
Posted by Slappjack Jul 17 · 2:08 PM EDT

12 team dynasty 0.5ppr 4 points passing TD, 6 for rushing.

Would you drop Elijah Mcguire for C. Thompson? I am a Guice owner.

Who would you rather have out of the following?...

12 team dynasty 0.5ppr 4 points passing TD, 6 for rushing.

Would you drop Elijah Mcguire for C. Thompson? I am a Guice owner.

Who would you rather have out of the following?
Mark Andrews
V. Mcdonald
A. Hooper
I. Thomas
J. Reed
Gesciki

See more
Posted by Ncarroll77 Jul 17 · 9:09 AM EDT

Hey guys welcome back! Im joining a 14 team keeper auction league. $225 budget. Keeping Cooper at $29, Godwin at $6 and Henry at $6. Guy is offering me 2 potential trades:

Juju $18 and...

Hey guys welcome back! Im joining a 14 team keeper auction league. $225 budget. Keeping Cooper at $29, Godwin at $6 and Henry at $6. Guy is offering me 2 potential trades:

Juju $18 and Cohen $17 for
Cooper $29 and Godwin $6

OR

Godwin at $6 straight up for Kerryon at $23

What are your thoughts on both?
Thanks!

See more
Posted by Rweezer04 Jul 16 · 11:57 PM EDT

Standard scoring 12 man keeper league
1 keeper per team
Lose the round the player was drafted in the year prior

OPTIONS
Mahomes Round 16
Kittle Round 13
J...

Standard scoring 12 man keeper league
1 keeper per team
Lose the round the player was drafted in the year prior

OPTIONS
Mahomes Round 16
Kittle Round 13
J Howard Round 12

Who would you keep? Thanks!

See more
Posted by adrake400 Jul 15 · 9:24 PM EDT

Barkley 1st Rd - 6th overall
Edelman 8th Rd
Godwin 11th Rd
McKinnon 16th Rd

I like the thought of Edelman for an 8th and grabbing a WR in the 1st (Hopkins/Adams) if...

Barkley 1st Rd - 6th overall
Edelman 8th Rd
Godwin 11th Rd
McKinnon 16th Rd

I like the thought of Edelman for an 8th and grabbing a WR in the 1st (Hopkins/Adams) if available, then hammering RB in the 2nd and 3rd. Thoughts?

See more
Posted by Sscastro Jul 15 · 6:13 PM EDT

PPR - Should I keep James White or...

PPR - Should I keep James White or Sony Michel? White is WAY, WAY, ahead of Michel in the seasonal rankings, but Michel is higher in dynasty rankings. I always draft to win now and don't really worry about dynasty rankings but wanted to get your advice. I'm currently shopping Michel and have gotten some good offers for him. Thanks

See more
Posted by Fatdog13 Jul 11 · 1:14 PM EDT

200 auction bucks
Ertz for 20
Chubb for 10
...

200 auction bucks
Ertz for 20
Chubb for 10
Aaron Jones for 7
Who would you guys keep?

See more
Posted by Fatdog13 Jul 11 · 1:08 PM EDT

2rbs 3wr .5ppr league! Do I keep ...

2rbs 3wr .5ppr league! Do I keep David Johnson or devante Adams? Already keeping Ertz,Kamara and Thielan. I have great late round value on them cause I drafted them 2 years ago. 100 yard bonus for wr and rb. Please help

See more
Posted by mrmainevent Jul 10 · 7:35 PM EDT

Todd gurley needs to be signed to a contract. Do I sign him to a 4 yr, 3 yr, 2 yr or 1 yr. I lose him when contract expires. Thoughts?

See more
Posted by BlacknGoldBlood Jul 06 · 1:46 PM EDT

So I entered my league scoring system into the site. Quarterbacks get 1 point per completion. 1 point per rush. Between 7 and 30 points for TD’s, depending on length. 1 point per 30 yards passing...

So I entered my league scoring system into the site. Quarterbacks get 1 point per completion. 1 point per rush. Between 7 and 30 points for TD’s, depending on length. 1 point per 30 yards passing. So I look on the cheatsheet for my scoring system and it has Mayfield listed on top with over 151,000 points. Has to be a glitch, right?
Sent from my iPad

See more
Posted by gnarlbard Jul 09 · 3:35 PM EDT

I'm in a 12-team, 2-player keeper league QB/RB/RB/WR/WR/WR/TE/FLEX.

...

I'm in a 12-team, 2-player keeper league QB/RB/RB/WR/WR/WR/TE/FLEX.

George Kittle- 9th round
Andrew Luck- 6th round
Nick Chubb- 13th round

I'm 100% planning on keeping Kittle, but I'm struggling with choosing my second keeper.

I think Luck is going to have another great year and represents great value for the QB position-- he'll have consistent, high-value every week.

Chubb is also great and for the value, you really can't beat it, but I'm worried about the inconsistency in scoring each week. With 2 stud receivers, a good TE, and a possible return of Kareem Hunt, I'm worried about his end of season production (playoff weeks).

I'd like to get your opinion on who I should keep

See more
Posted by jtswanson Jul 08 · 4:50 PM EDT

Hi there! I've unfortunately been unable to convince my league to drop the K position and generally believe in streaming both K/DEF.

Because we draft before the end of the preseason, I...

Hi there! I've unfortunately been unable to convince my league to drop the K position and generally believe in streaming both K/DEF.

Because we draft before the end of the preseason, I usually don't draft either of these positions in case of 1.) injuries and 2.) preseason trades with others in my league.

Would love your thoughts on where & how you address these positions during the draft in your leagues. Thanks!

See more
Posted by jranalli15 Jul 08 · 12:13 PM EDT

With the ability to keep James White in the...

With the ability to keep James White in the 9th round, and having the 3rd pick in a 12 team league snake draft, I was wondering if it would pay off more to target top end WRs in the early rounds, already having an option RB2/Flex in the 9th

See more
Posted by adrake400 Jul 01 · 5:12 PM EDT

10 team 1pt ppr super flex. Must start 1 WR & 1 RB. Can start up to 4 WR or RBs.

Give up:
M.Evans
D.Guice

Receive:
M.Gordan
A.Ekeler

Current WRs (...

10 team 1pt ppr super flex. Must start 1 WR & 1 RB. Can start up to 4 WR or RBs.

Give up:
M.Evans
D.Guice

Receive:
M.Gordan
A.Ekeler

Current WRs (Excluding Evans)
D.Hopkins
A.Cooper
K.Stills
S.Watkins
K.Golladay
J.Whiteside

Current RBs:
L.Miller
K.Drake
L.Murray
M.Brown
C.Edmonds
M Sanders
Duke Johnson

See more
Posted by Rock and Roll Jul 01 · 7:05 AM EDT

Hey Guys,

Happy July !! How much do you value last season’s actual (not fantasy) defensive rankings? Players upcoming schedule (especially playoff schedule) used to play a huge part in...

Hey Guys,

Happy July !! How much do you value last season’s actual (not fantasy) defensive rankings? Players upcoming schedule (especially playoff schedule) used to play a huge part in who I draft but I think it’s been proven that you can’t predict with it much accuracy. Maybe assume the top and bottom 5 may be the respectively bad or good. How do you use defense rankings ? Is there a place to get accurate information this early or do you just wait til week 4 when 4for4’s info comes out and go from there. Thoughts and Thanks.

See more
Posted by mikew14 Jun 29 · 2:37 PM EDT

ive been offered n. chubb and a 1st in 2020 for todd gurley? what do you guys think?

he also has joe mixon. should i counter with an offer for him instead? and if so, what kind of offer...

ive been offered n. chubb and a 1st in 2020 for todd gurley? what do you guys think?

he also has joe mixon. should i counter with an offer for him instead? and if so, what kind of offer? straight up? picks?

See more
Posted by Rock and Roll Jun 26 · 7:37 AM EDT

I see Mathew Stanford is ranked in the mid 20s. I guess he played with s broken back last year. What am I missing here. I guess their are just more quality quarterbacks. Thoughts and Thanks....

I see Mathew Stanford is ranked in the mid 20s. I guess he played with s broken back last year. What am I missing here. I guess their are just more quality quarterbacks. Thoughts and Thanks.

See more
Posted by Rock and Roll Jun 25 · 9:10 PM EDT

What Up Guys,

At the moment I am keeping ...

What Up Guys,

At the moment I am keeping DeAndre Hopkins. I might have a chance to trade down from the 2nd overall-pick to 3rd overall pick and acquire A. Kamara. We keep 1 player. The reason that I am hesitant is that the way keepers may work out I might have to draft M. Thomas or face a serious drop off in points with the other available selections. I do not want to have my two best players on the same NFLteam (The Saints). My thinking is that it becomes an either or target situation. Where in a perfect world I would rather each player be available for each available target on 2 different teams (Does that make sense ??). Basically, do you have a problem with having a RB and WR on the same NFL team on your team. Hence you would have A.Kamra and M. Thomas in your fantasy team. Also, who would you rather keep A.Kamara or D. Hopkins. Thoughts and thanks.

See more
Posted by Rweezer04 Jun 25 · 8:39 PM EDT

Hey guys,

I am in a 12 man 1pt ppr league (1qb 2rb 3wr 1te 2flx league). Who would you keep out of these four players? You lose the round they were drafted in.
C MAC - round 1 (I am...

Hey guys,

I am in a 12 man 1pt ppr league (1qb 2rb 3wr 1te 2flx league). Who would you keep out of these four players? You lose the round they were drafted in.
C MAC - round 1 (I am the 12th pick in this years draft)
Alvin Kamara - round 12 (no brainer)
Adam Theilen - round 7
Tyreek Hill - round 16

Thanks for the help!

See more
Posted by brianballard15 Jun 23 · 2:26 PM EDT

I'm in a 2 qb league and sitting at the seven spot. what are you guys thoughts on building out the team, if i'm probably not getting a top 5 rb. Should i go Rb/Rb or Wr/rb.. ??

See more