3 Overvalued Fantasy Football Quarterbacks for 2026

Aug 28, 2026

IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Week-to-week and year-to-year quarterback performances are arguably the easiest to predict among any of the typical fantasy positions. With a relative lack of injury concerns and baseline usage depending on the offensive scheme they are in, we can usually make median projections that line up with output at a much higher rate than our other starting positions. That doesn’t mean we will not have outlier performances, and sadly, that can mean players going in a positive or negative direction.

For this exercise, I compared current 4for4 rankings and Multi-Site average draft position (ADP) with a 43-player sample of 2025 quarterback efficiency and fantasy production. The three quarterbacks below are all capable of producing strong seasons. My concern is whether their current draft prices leave enough room for them to beat expectations.