This is so weird that I read this question today... I was just posting some news stories about ESPN seeing the Eagles RBs as a potential issue this year. And also posted a story that talked about Collins being the favorite to be the Raven's RB1. It got me interested enough that, just minutes ago, I had to look and see where we ranked each of these backs - and if you haven't looked Ajayi was 19th and Collins 17th in PPR I believe it was. Little surprised by this as I thought Ajayi would be higher.

I think Collins has a better chance to lose more carries and I know that sounds odd considering the Eagles were a full-blown committee last year. But Dixon seems to be lurking and apparently the Ravens haven't really committed to Collins.

I don't think I'd do this deal the way things stand right now. I think Ajayi is a safer bet to see a safer workload. There doesn't seem to be a direct threat behind Ajayi that can carry the load, where Dixon is certainly capable of stealing the job from Collins. But then again, it does give you some security having all the backs.

Value-wise, I don't think I'd do it though. Overall, I think the deal makes some sense for you. I would try to hold off and keep an eye on the Ravens RB situation this summer. You may not have to make this deal and you could end up better off for not doing it if Dixon somehow emerges...