Fantasy Upside
Tyrod Taylor has put up respectable numbers in his first two years as the Bills' starting quarterback, throwing for over 3,000 yards and rushing for over 500 yards in both seasons. In 2016, he reached those numbers without leading wide receiver Sammy Watkins for half the season. Also, he's thrown only a combined 12 interceptions on 817 attempts the last two years. Taylor is only 27, so there is a chance he will still get better. The Bills brought in new offensive coordinator Rick Dennison, who runs the West Coast offense, which plays to the strength of a quarterback with Taylor's skill set.
Fantasy Downside
One question for Buffalo: are there enough weapons for Taylor? The answer is yes and no. Watkins is a legitimate No. 1 receiver and LeSean McCoy is a legit all-purpose back. However, after that, there are question marks. The Bills did draft WR Zay Jones in the second round, but rookie receivers are a crapshoot on how impactful they can be. Plus, with a new coaching staff led by head coach Sean McDermott, do they believe in Taylor?
2017 Bottom Line
It's a tough call with Taylor. It could be a reach if you draft him as your No. 1 QB, but there is a chance his numbers go up. His ADP is low enough in the late rounds of most drafts, which makes him less risky of a pick. If you think the Bills offense will prosper under McDermott and Dennison, you could reach for him a round or two earlier than his ADP to serve as a high-end No. 2 QB on your roster. As of now, Taylor ranks as a tier three QB with an above average chance to outproduce his ADP.