Hi Scouts. I have a bit of a complicated scenario, and I was wondering if you could offer advice as to what I should do.

My keepers are currently Mike Evans (3rd Round Compensation this Year) and Sammy Watkins (5th Round Compensation this Year). Evans' keeper contract ends this year (he goes back into the pool of available players next year), while Watkins is kept through the 2018-19 season.

I have the option to keep LeSean McCoy (2nd round Compensation this Year), but this would force me to buy out Watkins contract. The result of this would mean that I would lost my 10th round pick this year, and 9th round pick in 2018-19, but not have to give up a 5th round pick in compensation this year to keep Watkins

Which option would you therefore prefer from my standpoint:

Keep Watkins on contract (and thus lose my 5th round pick this year because of compensation), keep my 2nd round pick from this year, and keep my 10th round pick from this year.

OR

Keep McCoy (and thus lose my 2nd round pick because of compensation), keep my 5th round pick this year, lose my 10th round pick this year (from buying out Watkins), and lose my 9th round pick next year (from buying out Watkins).

4for4 seems to be really low on Watkins this year, so I lean towards keeping McCoy. Also, because it's a keeper league and less top talent is available, McCoy would the top player available from a relative value standpoint. Still a bit unsure though given Watkins upside and cost of buying him out. Seems steep.

Sorry for the complex scenario and thank you for your help.