Honestly, I love it. I think moving down to 5, you still get a top notch back or WR and moving up in rounds is nice. The second rounders in the next couple of years will be big moves for you, so I'm all in. I say do it.

I was going to suggest instead of moving up in two rounds to flop a pick like you are talking about, where you take a pick of his higher in a round for one of yours lower in a round. I've done more trades that way but as the years have gone by, owners pretty much demand that you just flop in the same round and lose a few spots. I've always been the guy to have an extra keeper or trying to move down to be honest, I've never really been in a position to move up but I can see how he wouldn't want to do it for three spots. He may just talk himself into a tier of players like you have.

Maybe try to do his 3rd for your 5th or even 4th, if he'd do it for the 4th then maybe see if you can move up in a couple of rounds like the original deal too. I think you have to make it worth your while the more I'm thinking about this....

I don't think it's a bad deal, especially if you're happy to target the players you mentioned. You're moving up a couple of spots in some rounds so that's pretty good. You may be able to get him to swap a little more and I would probably at least try to see if you can pull that off. If he values your pick he just might do it. Just because you're happy to take any of a few players there doesn't mean you should give it up easy... But I could live with that deal.