What is a good way to factor in risk when ranking early round players of the same position, with similar projected values? Over the years I've found a lot of topics that point out that risk should be calculated into your player rankings but they never truly explain how.

Scott Pagel 4for4 Scout

I think injury history is the biggest for me. Gut feeling also plays in. For me, owning a player in the past who went to total crap will usually scar me at least for the next year. Doug Martin is a good example of this. I believe it was last year everyone jumped back on his bandwagon it seemed and he was going in 2nd/3rd round, but I stayed far away as a previous owner who lived through the bad days.

Maybe a better example is Arian Foster who is borderline first round talent... He's probably a guy I'd stay away from. When he's on the field, he's great, but the odds of that haven't been great lately it seems. It's also personal preference really and I don't think there's a set way to determine it other than if it comes down to say Foster or Forte or Murray when I'm looking for an RB, I'd go another direction than Foster.

Jun 18, 2015 ยท 10:21 AM EDT