Keeper league, should I pick up Manning or Garoppolo? I already have Locker, Foles, Austin Davis, Kaepernick and Glennon. I would drop Pierre Thomas to pick one of them [I have the first pick].
I'm okay dropping Locker. I think you have similar upside guys with Davis and Glennon, and you probably won't get to them anyway with Foles and Kap.
I don't see Garoppolo being valuable until Brady retires though, which I doubt will be next offseason. So if you're making an upgrade, then I'm okay with picking up Eli. Or if you feel like you can afford to stash Jimmy G. for 2-3 years, then I'm not opposed to it. Depends how your league works.
If you're in a 2QB league, then I think you should grab Eli, but if you're in a 1 QB league, then I think you're set with what you have and I'd rather see you hang on to Pierre.
What about dropping Locker or Bostick [GB TE] instead of PT? It is a 1 QB league.
